/sw/ - Star Wars

The board for discussing all things Star Wars


New Reply[×]
Name
Email
Subject
Message
Files Max 5 files50MB total
Tegaki
Password
Flag
[New Reply]


ClipboardImage.png
[Hide] (507.9KB, 400x990)
ClipboardImage.png
[Hide] (1.1MB, 985x1028)
In the films and video games, lightsaber users typically default to something like a plow/longpoint/seigan. I don't think these are the worst possible stance, but are really focused on things a lightsaber doesn't really need (lightsabers need relatively little speed/force to do serious damage) and leaves a lot of the body open to blasters.

I think something like saber's outside half-hanging guard would actually be the default for anyone who expects to fight blasters instead of other sabers (basically everyone post-Russan).  It lets the user cover a very large portion of their body with ease just by shoulder movements (only very bottom of the feet aren't protected here, and those are a pretty poor blaster target as is). It allows advancing quickly with relatively little loss in coverage and for someone like Kyle Katarn, it allows quickly drawing a blaster and shooting people who are overly focused on your saber.

How do you think saber combat ought to do differently than it's normally depicted?
Replies: >>5894
Ain't jedi suppose to rely in faster than human reflexes and precog to deflect blasters? So even with a straight energy bar than can do their deflect shots back trick.
Replies: >>5637
>>5630
Yes, but that doesn't mean they shouldn't stand/hold their saber in a way that makes it easy.
Replies: >>5643
>>5637
It's just moving an weightless energy bar, the only actual weight and movement is done by moving the hilt/emitter around
>How do you think saber combat ought to do differently than it's normally depicted?
There are plenty of non conventional lightsaber variations around in the EU
Replies: >>5645
>>5643
The blade may be weightless (Actually, is this ever made explicit?), but the bar and the user's arm still take time and energy to move.
Replies: >>5657 >>5663
>>5645
How much do you think a magnetic contained plasma bar weights?
>>5645
if a creature like kazdan paratus can make and wield a lightsaber, its safe to say the blade its weightless and the rest of the saber carries all the weight.
Replies: >>5713
>>5663
Why does Yoda use a short saber then?
Replies: >>5714
>>5713
Proper control, precision, the blade is proportional to his size. How a midget would effectively use what amounts to a lance? Even with a lightsaber proportional to his size he needed to hop around like a frantic frog to face human sized foes. It isn't a question of mere weight there.
Replies: >>5881
>>5714
Lance doesn't really depend on your height if it's in a lance rest. Long spear actually works pretty fine on a short individual.
I disagree with some of his points but I think overall it's pretty sound:
https://yewtu.be/watch?v=s8cwM3-uowQ
>>5629 (OP) 
In a real fight, yeah you would use a lightsaber different then you used a normal sword. But that shit looks gay so they went with something that's visually appealing to normalfags.
[New Reply]
11 replies | 2 files
Connecting...
Show Post Actions

Actions:

Captcha:

- news - rules - faq -
jschan 1.7.3